Back to Blog

7 High-Protein Sweet Treats

recipes Apr 12, 2023

I'm Kylee Arnold, your personal nutrition coach, accountability partner and motivator. I'ma busy mom that lives in South Louisiana, so I get the struggles of  restricted time and endless temptations when trying to reach your fat loss goals. I had tried many diets and approaches to achieve my goal body, but   always wondered, was this what I needed? Was this the best way for me? And how can I make this fit into my day-to-day   life! If you have these same questions and want to know if working 1:1 with a coach would be a good fit, schedule a free discovery call today!



7 High Protein Sweet Treats


My clients often think they have to eliminate certain foods when starting with ANC and that is almost never the case. I encourage my clients to plan their treats so they don't overindulge or feel guilty about having the treat And most clients, also need more protein in their diet so what better way than to combine the two :)

Weather you like a sweet breakfast, dessert, after dinner or a midday snack these treats will satisfy your tastebuds and your tummy!

If you're interested in knowing exactly which foods work best for you and your goals and how to pair foods together. Schedule a call here for a free consult to see if 1-on-1 nutrition coaching is for you!


1. Mug Cake



There are so many ways to make these from scratch but I like to cheat a little to make it easy ;)



Protein Pancake Mix

Mix ins of choice i.e. berries, chocolate chips. peanut butter, etc.

Toppings of choice i.e. Whipped cream, jelly, light syrup, ice cream etc.



Take a small bowl, coffee mug, or ramekin. Put 3-4 tbsp of the protein mix in the container. Add water a tbsp at a time until a pancake batter consistency is achieved. Add mix-ins. Microwave for 1 - 1:30 min.

Add toppings and enjoy!


2. Sweet Oatmeal Bowl




This is an obvious breakfast staple for many but I also love oatmeal as a sweet treat at night! Like most of these recipes there are so many ways to make these but here is what I like to start with!



1/4 cup old fashioned oats

1/4 cup cauliflower rice (optional but adds volume and fiber)

2 tbsp PB2 Powder

1 serving protein powder (works with almost any flavor!)

Mixins of choice i.e. chocolate chips, berries, nuts, etc.


Microwave cauliflower rice first for 2 min until tender. Add oatmeal and 1/4 cup water and put back in microwave for 3 min. (keep an eye out so it doesn't boil over)

Remove from microwave (may be a little watery but that's okay!) and let cool before adding protein powder or it will get lumpy.

Then add mixins and enjoy!

*Slowly add water or milk if too thick


3. Protein Balls



Keeping up with versatile desserts are our protein balls. We call these our King Cake Protein Balls but can be enjoyed any time of year ;)



45 grams Rolled Oats
2 scoops vanilla protein powder
1 Tbl Nutritional Yeast
40g dates, pitted
1.5 oz Greek cream cheese or Greek yogurt
1 Tbl Cinnamon


In a medium bowl, soak the pitted dates in 2 cups of warm water for 10 minutes. Drain and set aside.
In the bowl of a food processor, pulse together the oatmeal, nutritional yeast and protein powder until the oatmeal is broken down but not quite a powder. Move to a bowl.
Place the soaked dates, cream cheese or yogurt and Vietnamese cinnamon and pulse until this mixture is well blended. Scrape into the bowl with the oatmeal mixture and combine together. Scoop out and roll the batter into roughly 1-inch balls.
Makes 10 balls


4. High Protein Cheesecake



One of my staples and favs! Again mix up flavors and topping to make it yoru own!



1 pre-made mini graham cracker crust

1 scoop protein powder (flavor of choice)
2 ounces light cream cheese, softened
1/4 cup Greek yogurt

1 tbsp low-calorie granulated sweetener or honey
1/4 cup berries or mixed fruit



Mix all ingredients except for berries together, may mix better with an electric mixer. Fill crust with the filling and top with berries. Chill and enjoy!


5. Protein Cereal + High Protein Milk



I mean this isn't really a recipe but there is nothing better than cereal and cold milk at night IMO!

Choose a high protein cereal such as:

Catalina Crunch

Three Wishes

Magic Spoon

Nature's Path, etc.


Pair with a higher protein milk such as:



Whole Milk


If you really want to increase protein, pour a protein shake over your cereal, yum!!!


6. Yogurt and berries



A very simple combo but often not thought of!

You can do flavored yogurt and pair fruit with it but I like to buy plain yogurt and add mix-ins.



3/4 cup whole milk yogurt

1 scoop flavored protein powder or PB2

Berries or mixins of choice

Whipped cream optional


7. Brownies



Where are my chocolate lovers at?! This one is for you and so easy!



1 cup Pumpkin puree can sub for sweet potato or banana
1/2 cup almond butter can sub for peanut butter, cashew butter or a nut butter alternative
1/4 cup cocoa powder
1-2 scoops protein powder
1 serving liquid stevia



Preheat the oven to 180C/350F and line a mini muffin tin with mini muffin liners- For smaller brownie bites, you'll need at least 15. Ensure each muffin tin in greased generously.

In a high speed blender or mixing bowl, combine all your ingredients and blend/mix until smooth.
Pour brownie mixture into each muffin tin, filling until just full. As there is no baking powder needed, they generally won't rise.

Bake for 12-15 minutes, or until a skewer/toothpick comes out just clean. Allow to cool in the muffin tin completely. For best results, refrigerate once cooled for several hours

Recipe courtesy of The Big Man's World



If you're ready to see what working with a nutrition coach is like, book your consult here. On your consult, we will talk about your goals and history and how we will build a plan for you to help you succeed! No pressure to sign up!


"I have struggled with my weight for so long. Kylee is the only person to help me be successful. I am so happy that I chose Arnold Nutrition Coaching." 

Kirstin Esquivel


Want more Grocery Guides?! Click here to download the Ultimate BR Grocery guides which includes: Rouses, CostCo, Target and OakPoint!